After I sent yesterday's reply to the Bishop, The Star has published another response to my letter. Would anyone else care to reply? starletters@inl.co.za
Promoting a rational world-view in Africa, the continent most blighted by superstition.
Wednesday, 23 January 2013
Tuesday, 22 January 2013
Bible Cannot be Reconciled with Science, and Must be Rejected
Sent
to The Star, Johannesburg (starletters@inl.co.za) Tue 22/01/2013
21:14.
Sir
Bishop Moagi Khunou’s letter “Much agreement between Bible
and true science” (The Star, January 21, copy below) is a classic piece on how religion
deals with pesky facts.
First, if you don’t have a good response, denigrate your
opponent’s views as “hackneyed and discredited” without refuting them.
Then, profess Special Knowledge. Your opponent is deluded, as indeed are many
Christians, but you know better.
In fact, denigrate anyone likely to disagree: They are
“casual or simplistic minds”, not “serious students”.
Knock down some straw men and deliberate misunderstandings
of your opponent’s position, throw in a few apparent “facts”, a casual lie like
a deathbed conversion of Darwin, skirt around anything difficult, and you’re
done –what could be easier?
Only a believer is qualified to criticise the Bible? Hardly. Reading the Bible with an open mind
is one of the surest routes to atheism
Let us confront what the Bishop avoided:
I was refuting Mr Lee’s claim that the Bible is “the
infallible and inerrant Word of God”. I
showed that it is not inerrant (error-free) as it has serious mistakes, and not
infallible (incapable of error) as it has been modified over time. I said nothing about whether God personally
wrote the Bible, one of the Bishop’s straw men.
There are plenty of professing Christians who believe that
the Earth is less than 10,000 years old, including about 30% of US citizens:
They are called “Young-Earth Creationists”.
However the Bishop is welcome to believe that a Divine Space Opera took
place between the first two verses of Genesis.
Let’s also ignore that in Genesis 1, God creates plants
first and man last, after all other animals, but in Genesis 2 He creates man
first.
What we can’t ignore is that in Genesis 1, God creates day
and night on the first “day”, and then it was evening and morning (a literal
day –not an “age”). Plants are created on the third day, and the sun, moon, and
stars on the fourth day. Thus we have
day and night proceeding before the creation of the sun. The earth is supposedly older (much older,
the Bishop claims) than the sun, which is itself two days older than Adam. Please try to reconcile this with science!
The Bishop claims that there is agreement between the Bible
and “true science”. “True science” is a
tautology: If it’s not true, it’s not science.
No doubt the Bishop only regards as true the parts of science that don’t
contradict his myths.
There is a big difference between a Bible written by
fallible men, and science done by fallible men.
Science is self-correcting.
Experimental results –facts– are checked against the proposed
model. There is stringent peer
review. Scientists compete for the best
explanation that fits reality.
Hypotheses that do not work are discarded.
Religious books, on the other hand, are not rewritten when
they prove inaccurate. The believer is
not encouraged to check that his beliefs match reality. Instead he is called upon to believe
ever-more absurd things in order to demonstrate his “faith”.
For example… If all the eight-million-odd species on earth
were on Noah’s Ark and got off on Mt Ararat, isn't it strange that we find
marsupials only in Australia? The Bishop
seems to believe that they ran and swam (or built boats?) all the way there
without any being left behind!
Continental Drift, coupled with evolution, is a much sounder
explanation.
Note how the Bishop skirts the genealogy of Jesus. “The Saviour had to be born in the house
of David” –what nonsense is this? Does
the Bishop know how babies are made?
Matthew 1-16 deals only with the male line: Either Joseph is Jesus’s genetic
father, in which case Jesus is the “son” of David, the “son” of Abraham –but not
the Son of God– or, if God inseminated Mary, then Jesus can be claimed as the
“Son of God” but he has no family tree, and the “prophecies” are false.
Of course the Bishop has no answer to the 500-year
difference between the conflicting so-called genealogies of Jesus in Matthew 1
and Luke 3. If God “inspired” Matthew
and Luke, he “inspired” at least one of them to lie.
We can find biblical phrases that can be shoe-horned into
agreeing with modern science after the fact.
Nevertheless, the Bible has been used, and continues to be used, to
suppress science and human rights. One
thinks of church persecution of Galileo and Copernicus, the “Creationism”
rampant in the US, and persecution of gays in Africa.
Labels:
atheism,
Bible,
bible contradictions,
Bishop Moagi Khunou,
Charles Darwin,
Christianity,
Christopher Hitchens,
Deathbed Conversion,
Jesus genealogy,
Luke 3,
Matthew 1,
superstition
Location:
Johannesburg, South Africa
Monday, 7 January 2013
The Second Coming of John Lee
Sent to The Star, Johannesburg (starletters@inl.co.za) Mon 07/01/2013 09:32. Published minus the parts in blue [plus parts in red] Monday 14 January 2012 as “Bible is contradictory, a product of fallible men”.
I refer to John Lee’s letter “Nobody will determine end of days, only God” (The Star, Monday January 7 2013).
Mr Lee needs to check his assumptions. The Bible is not “the infallible and inerrant Word of God”, as he believes, and one can prove this easily.
First proof - objective reality: The two creation myths in the Bible are both wrong. They can in no way be reconciled with the true age of the earth as corroborated by many scientific methods. The tale of Noah’s ark begs the question: How did all the kangaroos get to Australia and the llamas to Peru?
Second Proof - logic: A document that contradicts itself cannot be true. The self-contradictions in the Bible are many and well-documented. Among the more glaring ones are [Such as] the two conflicting genealogies of Jesus in Matthew 1 and Luke 3. From Abraham to David the records agree. From David to Joseph there are serious discrepancies. Luke has 40 generations between the two; Matthew has 25, a difference of about 480 years.*
Matthew 1 starts “This is the genealogy of Jesus the Messiah the son of David, the son of Abraham”. When he gets to Jesus in verse 16, he contradicts himself, saying “…Jacob the father of Joseph, the husband of Mary, and Mary was the mother of Jesus”. The original writer of the book of Matthew probably had Joseph as the father of Jesus. A later writer then grafted in the “Son of God” myth, apparently not realizing that if God was the father of Jesus, then Mary’s cuckolded husband Joseph and his entire descent were irrelevant.
Third proof – the Bible has changed: Since Mr Lee has internet access, he should look up the book “Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why” by Bart D. Ehrman, and the web site www.codexsinaiticus.org which deals with Codex Sinaiticus, the "Sinai Bible". The latter is over 1600 years old and includes the oldest complete copy of the New Testament. It differs substantially from modern Bibles, and from slightly younger versions like Codex Vaticanus and Alexandrinus. There are literally thousands of differences, many minor, some major, between these early versions of the Bible and the one Mr Lee reads. How can something that appears in so many different versions be infallible or inerrant, let alone the “Word of God”?
*Footnote: I have set up a spreadsheet comparing the Old testament, Matthew 1, and Luke 3's genealogies of Jesus. e-mail me if you'd like a copy.
Sunday, 15 July 2012
We are not meant to know! Let superstition and ignorance prevail!
Sent
to The Star, Johannesburg, Sun 15/07/2012 12:34, published Tuesday
July 17 (minus the parts in blue) as
“Archaic logic makes little sense”. Dr
Levin’s original letter is below.
Sir
Amazing how even a
breakthrough like the discovery of the Higgs Boson can be spun in favour of
superstition by proponents like Dr A. M Levin (“Accept what we are meant to
know”, in The Star, Thursday July 12).
Contrary to what Dr
Levin may think, we know a considerable amount about the “how” of the universe:
Much more than was known by the authors of the bible.
As to “why” the
universe exits, it is a meaningless question, based on an assumption that there
must be a reason for everything. This sort of
thinking caused men to invent gods in the first place.
If we had meekly believed that we were “not meant to
know” things not “revealed” in scripture, we would still accept plagues and
natural disasters as punishments from the gods. Instead, vaccination and
weather forecasts save lives uncounted; billions
live longer, healthier and happier lives than ever before in history.
It is sad when
educated people like Dr Levin (who seems to be a
medical practitioner), in professions based on science, nevertheless try
to retard progress with outdated and discredited texts like the bible.
If Dr Levin wants
to quote Deuteronomy, would he also like us to not eat rabbit, pork or calamari
(Deuteronomy 14:7-10), or stone to death non-virgin brides (Deuteronomy
22:20-21), or make rape victims marry rapists (Deuteronomy 22:28-29), or
prevent banks charging interest (Deuteronomy 23:19)?
Labels:
A. M Levin,
atheism,
Bible,
Deuteronomy,
Higgs Boson,
scripture
Location:
Johannesburg, South Africa
Sunday, 17 June 2012
Promoting Religion is Reprehensible
Sent to The Star, Johannesburg, Sun 17/06/2012 16:19, not published.
An acquaintance sent me an e-mailed PowerPoint presentation, “Center of the Bible”. Here is my reply, which deserves a wider audience:
Dear Neil
I am sure you meant no harm in sending me your chain-letter e-mail promoting religion, the bible, and prayer. No doubt you believed it was a Good Thing to do. Let me explain why I find it reprehensible.
Imagine that you got an e-mail from me inviting you to a festival of the Sun God, based on ancient Egyptian writings. We will offer prayers and, to ensure good rains and a bountiful crop, will be sacrificing some first-born: Yours might be lucky enough to be included. You should command your wife and slaves to attend as well.
I’d expect a sharp reply from you castigating me for my barbarism and superstition, pointing out that the Sun is a common star with no supernatural powers, that praying and sacrificing to it will not influence the weather or crops, that your wife is an adult who makes her own decisions, and that no decent person today owns slaves.
Now, make two changes to my hypothetical invitation: Replace “Egyptian writings” with “Bible”, and “Sun God” with your name for God.
Human sacrifice is a theme running through the Bible from Isaac to Exodus to Jesus: Indeed, it is a central tenet of Christianity that it is a good thing to torture an innocent man to death in the place of the guilty. Civilised? I don’t think so.
The Old Testament gives detailed commandments for the keeping of slaves, including the requirements for selling your daughter into slavery. The New Testament supports it. The “Good Book’s” attitude towards women is that they are possessions: Witness Lot’s willingness to give his daughters to a mob to be raped. Good? I don’t think so.
As with many other books, the Bible contains its share of wisdom, but there is a lot of bad stuff there too. If you take the Bible as the word of a God that must be obeyed, you would murder me for speaking against Him, and kill everyone you know for working on the Sabbath.
I am worried when an educated 21st-Century person advocates the Bible as anything more than a myth from the infancy of our species. Today anybody with matric knows more about the universe than the authors of the Bible did. Yet your opinion of me is so low that you think I follow it.
The god depicted in the bible is a nasty piece of work: Rigid, jealous, angry, sectarian, misogynist and genocidal. Fortunately it is obviously also fictitious.
Prayer is at best a waste of time, and may well be counter-productive, as shown by scientific studies (for example, the 2006 "Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP)" led by Harvard Professor Herbert Benson). You’re entitled to your own opinions, but not your own facts.
In an age when religious fanatics who welcome Armageddon can get hold of nuclear weapons, you are doing our planet a grave disservice by spreading superstition. Please reconsider.
Thanks and RICKgards
Labels:
Bible,
Center of the Bible,
god,
gods,
Herbert Benson,
Human sacrifice,
prayer,
slaves,
STEP,
Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer
Location:
Johannesburg, South Africa
Sunday, 13 May 2012
Gay Marriage: Human Morality is not stuck in Biblical Times
Sent Sun 13/05/2012 15:00 to The Star Johannesburg, not published, and The Times, who published it.
President Barak Obama recently bravely endorsed gay marriage. This was followed by a chorus of opposition, most of it claiming to be Bible-based, specifically on Leviticus 18:22.
Apart from homosexuality, the Old Testament forbids many things that we do today: Working on the Sabbath (Exodus 31:14-15) (penalty: death), eating pork (Leviticus 11:7-8) and seafood (Leviticus 11:9-12), pre-marital sex (at least for women!) (Deuteronomy 22:20-21) (Penalty: death), wearing mixed materials, to name a few.
On the other hand, the Bible allows selling one’s children as slaves, and lays out a complex set of rules governing slavery (Leviticus 25:44-52, Exodus 21:1-11 and 20-21).
The bible also condones rape under certain conditions (Deuteronomy 22:28-29) and moreover forces the victim to marry the rapist: In March Amina Filali committed suicide rather than marry her rapist under Morocco’s barbaric "rape-and-marry" law.
Apart from occasionally wishing we could sell our troublesome brats, in the civilized world we have moved on from the morality of 3000 BC. We no longer condone slavery, nor regard women as commodities whose virginity is more valuable than the person. We do not stone to death people who gather sticks on the Sabbath (Numbers 15:32-36).
To our credit, modern morality is not based on the Bible, but rather on a consensus of fairness and tolerance developed gradually over centuries. This applies across most countries, irrespective of religion –or freedom from religion.
“Ah, but,” the religious apologist may contend, “we now follow the New Testament and Christ’s teaching that we treat others the way we want them to treat us” (Luke 6:31).
Fine. Then how about applying this principle to gay marriage too?
Sunday, 18 March 2012
Islam not only Accepts, it Promotes, Violence
Sent
to The Star, Johannesburg, Sunday 18/03/2012 22:14, not published as predicted.
Sir
I doubt
that the Editor will publish this, since the Star shows remarkable reluctance
to publish letters critical of Islam. Or perhaps it is not so surprising when
one considers how readily the proponents of the "Religion of Peace"
use violence when their religion is criticised.
I
must take issue with the statement of Dr Heldar Ali Balouji of the so-called
"Islamic Republic" (a serious contradiction in terms) of Iran , in the
Star of Tuesday March 13, "Islam does not accept harmful acts against
mankind".
A
few quotes from the Quran should dispel this misinformation.
[8.39] fight with them until ...religion should be only for Allah
[9.12] ..fight the leaders of unbelief..
[9.123] O you who believe! fight those of the unbelievers who are near
to you...
and
Muhammad’s Ultimatum to Foreign Kings: (9:29) “Fight with those from among the
people of the Book, who do not believe in Allah nor in the Last Day; who do not
make unlawful that which Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful, and do not
adopt the Right way as their way. Fight with them until they pay Jizyah with
their own hands and are humbled.” (Jizyah is a tax levied only on
non-Muslims)
Finally:
(4:34) "Men have authority over women because God has made the one
superior to the other, and because they spend their wealth to maintain them.
Good women are obedient. ... As for those from whom you fear disobedience,
admonish them and send them to beds apart and BEAT THEM." [my emphasis]
Here
I assume that Dr Balouji includes "womankind" within
"mankind": Perhaps, like many Islamacists, he doesn't. Or
maybe beating is not, in his opinion, a "harmful act".
Islam
not only accepts, it promotes, harmful acts against humanity.
What
other belief actively promotes martyrdom and mass murder?
Labels:
fight,
Iran,
Islam,
Johannesburg,
martyrdom,
Quran,
The Star,
violence,
women's rights
Location:
Johannesburg, South Africa
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




